Stop Romanticizing Victorian London

Book review: The Good Old Days: Crime, Murder and Mayhem in Victorian Londonby Gilda O’Neill (Amazon / Book Depository)

Author and historian Gilda O’Neill, well-known for her social history books exploring the changing face of London’s East End, examines the problems that plagued the “good old days” of the Victorian era, using the thesis that problems of the present day really aren’t all that different from the past, and the past is far less rosy than memory and glorified history would have us believe.

Despite a perception of the Victorian age as a kind of golden era of prosperity and safety from a societal sense, bolstered by its developments in technology and advancements towards modernity, O’Neill argues that it was actually a time of extremes, leading many sections of the population to turn to crime in order to survive. She’s remarkably effective in drawing parallels with the world of Victorian vice and modern society, and meticulous about providing examples to illustrate her points. I particularly liked her debunking of blaming video games for violence in modern youth, a tired old argument we’ve been hearing my entire lifetime and probably longer. But learn enough about history and it turns out that nothing is really new, the details and circumstances change but the core of human nature, especially in conditions of social shifts and poverty, doesn’t change too much.

Chapters are divided by vice, and look at problems like drug and alcohol dependency, crimes involving children and child abuse, murder, prostitution, common street crime like petty theft, and perhaps most intriguingly the section on cons, fraud and psychic crime. O’Neill presents cases that sparked public interest and exemplified social issues of the day. And of course, no book on Victorian criminal history in London, especially with its heavy focus on the East End, would be complete without a chapter devoted to Jack the Ripper. Historical episodes and explanations of specific crimes and cases are interspersed with the author’s own familial background and their experiences in various colorful London jobs.

As interesting as the subject material is, I didn’t enjoy the structure – the author presents a fairly good argument then inserts a big chunk of source to back it up, making it read more like an academic dissertation than a well-told history or work of narrative nonfiction. Long sections of the text are direct quotes from other sources that seem like they’d be more effective if woven into the narrative instead of extracted and used verbatim.

And sometimes the individual episodes didn’t go into enough detail, they seemed to be over before I’d found out all I wanted to know. But that can be a positive: it’s a quick read so serves as a solid introduction to the history of crime in the era and a jumping off point for additional topics of interest.

I absolutely loved her somewhat cynical assessment that, just like in the present day, if you were healthy, wealthy, and male, things would probably work out just fine; but if you were any combination of the opposites of those three things, you face a much tougher time. Some things never change.

The Good Old Days:
Crime, Murder and Mayhem in Victorian London

by Gilda O’Neill
published December 1, 2016 (new ebook edition) by Endeavour Press
originally published September 7, 2006 by Viking

I received an advance copy of the new ebook edition courtesy of the publisher for review.

Amazon / Book Depository

3 thoughts on “Stop Romanticizing Victorian London

Add yours

  1. Hey ! I just came across your blog and I think it’s really special! Though I always have a non-fiction book in my rotation, I read them more slowly than novels. They feel more like work than play, so it takes me a while to finish them. I will definitely be reading your posts to catch up on what I’m missing. I’m really curious about the “narrative” you mentioned about well written non-fiction.


    1. Thank you so much for that very nice compliment! I understand what you mean, I’ve read a lot of nonfiction that feels more like work, and although sometimes I think it’s worth it for an interesting topic or something I want to learn about, I’d rather it be fun! In the next week or so I’ll do a post of my best picks from 2016 and maybe you’ll see something interesting there 🙂

      By narrative I mean when it has a good, clear storyline, so it reads less textbookish or dry, but rather more like a novel, where you can get wrapped up in the author’s voice and not just try to absorb a recitation of facts or figures.

      Thanks again for the kind feedback!

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: