American Identity As Seen Through Food

Book review: Fed, White, and Blue, by Simon Majumdar (Amazon / Book Depository)

Food writer and “food expert,” whatever that means, Simon Majumdar relocated from his beloved England to Los Angeles to be with his girlfriend. Some time after their marriage, he was faced with the decision of becoming a US citizen.

This unleashes a torrent of silly non-issues, like does he have to give up being British, either via passport or notion of identity?! (No.) Does he have to stop saying “maths” and “sport”? (No.) But as food is the most important thing to him and his wife, he reminds with plenty of examples of hangriness, he decides to learn more about American cuisine by traveling the country and sampling various iterations of it. Then he’ll really know whether he wants to become American? Apparently. He has ways of putting it more interestingly, but that’s the core idea.

I knew from all my previous travels that the moment you talk to people about the food they eat or, better still, ask to eat with them, they open up not only their kitchens but also their lives, allowing you to experience a side of them that you might never normally be allowed to see.

As you may have noticed, I felt many burblings in my reservoir of annoyance reading this (Ross Gay would probably be unhappy with my repeated use of this line from his book celebrating the delightful, but it’s too perfect for describing when something starts going wrong in my liking of a book.)

This one went wrong early, in the foreword written by Alton Brown. It’s so fawning of a piece about how extraordinarily clever, impossibly talented, and all-around wonderful Simon Majumdar is that I wondered if it was a joke he’d authored himself. Then downhill further: Although it had some truly brilliant moments, and gave me a lot to think about in terms of how I consider my own identity – personal and national – through food, my annoyances piled up.

On his Fed, White, and Blue tour / journey (yes, he calls it that, and often, much to my chagrin), Majumdar covers many of the usual suspects – barbecues both classic and Korean, Maine lobster rolls, sampling Midwestern hot dish, salmon fishing in Alaska, beer-making, Wisconsin cheese, Central American food in the Bronx. Despite some frequently treaded ground, these had educational moments – I liked learning about the lobsters and why it’s such a precious commodity, for one.

Yet he doesn’t take the opportunity to highlight regional specialties like Wisconsin cheese curds, but rather, how Wisconsin cheesemaking is becoming more gourmet and European, commenting that it still has a long way to go to catch up but it’s getting there! What’s the point of celebrating what’s uniquely American about our food if it’s only a vehicle for complaining about how America’s efforts aren’t as good as European standards?

Why not highlight what’s quirky but delightful and meaningful for Americans of a region, and show us what that means for identity, culture, immigration backgrounds? He tries a little, but it’s all about him – overeating to the point of discomfort with a lot of judgment of others (and a competitive eating chapter that feels unnecessary – they’re cultural, sure, but are they really part of a broader culture in terms of what it means to be American? With a little shoehorn about paying for college with the competitions in there? It seems an extreme, not a norm.)

In the center, elevated from its counterparts like Excalibur rising from the lake, was the cheese which had won the coveted prize as Best in Show.

To be fair, that gave me a good laugh.

He frequently laments how tired he is from traveling the country eating, how many emails he has to catch up on, and how brilliantly wonderful his wife is, but how cranky when she doesn’t get the food she’s craving immediately, and the various fights they and other members of her family have over getting the last piece of meat on a plate (some iteration of this fighting-over-food story happens multiple three times, each unfunnier than the last).

All of this sounds bad, but I should clarify it’s not an altogether terrible book without redeeming attributes. It did introduce me to an interesting dish here or there (hello Korean corn cheese, which I can’t wait to make – no recipes here, which was fine). I think overall I didn’t like the author’s humor or writing style and sensed pretentiousness, plus the gimmickyness of the project instead of working towards deeper meaning bothered me. He writes that he had more than a hundred flights and visited 39 states but we see comparatively little. I would’ve liked something more well-rounded (most of the trips seem coordinated by famous chef or restaurateur friends) with less navel-gazing.

Then there are his descriptions of food, something that had turned me off to food memoirs for a long time. He praises things for having “clean tastes”. What does that even mean? And uses a formula repeatedly until I could sense it coming. Example: “the softness of the tortilla and the brain combining beautifully with the crunch of the salsa and the acidity of the lime juice.” Another: “the crunch of the onions, the acidity of the tomatoes, and finally, the main event…” It’s basically crunch of X + acidity of Y + (sometimes) texture of Z = main event [star ingredient]. Lazy TV cooking judge-speak.

“If one is going to write about the relationship the United States has with its food, it’s never going to be a completely rosy picture. I always knew that there would be darker aspects to experience if I wanted to get a true impression of Americans and the way they eat.” He does some due diligence regarding problematic aspects of American food culture in looking at the cattle / meatpacking industry and volunteering at a soup kitchen, and opines on the oversimplified emphasis on eating local, all-natural, etc. I appreciated this, but it felt undercooked, and uncomfortable since elsewhere he describes overstuffing himself.

He also does some kind of Southern fast-food experiment, but only writes a paragraph about its gross effects instead of examining anything more meaningful or illuminating about our fast food proclivities. I like vignettes, which these are, but think I might’ve liked it better if there were more vignettes from more locations and cuisines and less detail at each stop, as that’s where the bad jokes and grating commentary muscle in.

And occasionally, he incorporates a fascinating, if queasy, bit of science or history, like where cheese began: “No one is quite sure how this process was discovered, but many historians believe that, as some of the earliest containers for liquid were made from animal stomachs, there is a good chance that the first cheeses were created when the bag’s contents of milk accidentally became heated in the sun.”

Interesting concept, I didn’t gel with the writing style or voice. I did love what it made me consider, in terms of what cuisine means to me, culturally, as an American. 2.5/5

Fed, White, and Blue:
Finding America With My Fork

by Simon Majumdar
published 2015

Amazon / Book Depository

Advertisements

27 thoughts on “American Identity As Seen Through Food

    1. That’s such a good way of putting it, there was too much comparison instead of exploring and celebrating something for what it is. He does do a little of that, to be fair, but too little, too late and all felt very judgey. It did make me a bit defensive, I just ended up feeling more cranky than anything with it! Maybe because I’ve been looking forward to this one for a long time and it had much more potential than was realized.

      Liked by 1 person

  1. Ok you really have to try corn cheese. I first ordered it for my kids but I loved it too. The ones we’ve eaten at Korean restaurants here don’t have the capsicum that I saw in your link though. But they’re so buttery and cheesy

    Liked by 2 people

    1. I bookmarked that recipe because it was the only one I saw that used peppers and I love them. But it sounds amazing either way, maybe I’ll try it without first to see what it’s like. I don’t know how I’ve missed it in the Korean restaurants I’ve been to!

      Like

    1. To be fair he did cover Wisconsin cheese and a cheese festival, but mostly just griped about how European cheese is better. And yes, a sin to include no cheese curds at all!! I would’ve loved a look at the importance of regional specialties/recipes, those say a lot about a place and culture too. It was just a bit all over the place and I don’t think conveyed the message he was intending it to.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. It’s a mystery why publishers keep redoing the same types of book over and over, when their authors have noting new to say. Didn’t Calvin Trillin essentially do this one or two generations ago? Didn’t MFK Fisher do it in the 40s? Didn’t several other authors do it in the last few years?

    Your review is a good warning!

    best… mae at maefood.blogspot.com

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I think there’s a difference in books that give an expat or “outsider” perspective of places and what the author deems significant or worth exploring, especially for something like food, where writers foreign to a country highlight things that natives would maybe never consider. So I can see why it’s a crowded genre. And that would be why I think this type of book exists in addition to similar topics by the American authors you mentioned. (I’ve been meaning to read the Calvin Trillin trilogy that I think you’re referring to, I’ve heard it’s wonderful!) There’s also a lot of misunderstanding and bad stereotypes outside of the US about what American cuisine consists of, so any project that helps change that mindset is worthwhile, in my view. But the tone and other things in this one just didn’t work for me, I don’t think he ever quite got his focus right.

      Like

  3. Your reviews are always so thoughtful and insightful! This one has been on my to-read shelf for ages … probably since it came out. But from what you point out, the idea of comparison over exploration just isn’t that appealing in a food book. I like Majumdar a lot based on interviews, though, so I’ll probably get to it eventually. And corn cheese does sound delicious!

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Oh thank you so much, I’m so glad you think so!!

      What is he most known for, his Food Network appearances? I could see where maybe he’s more personable on TV than he comes across in writing, or maybe in cases where it’s not so personally focused. It did have some really wonderful elements, and I learned a few things I’m glad to know (that corn cheese exists, among them!!) I don’t think I’d seek out anything else by him because I think it’s his tone/style that especially didn’t work for me, but this one can be worth reading especially if you already like him.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Fabulous review! Sounds like something I will have to pass on, thanks for the heads up!

    I have tried to subscribe to your mailing list but it claims my comcast.net email is not valid. Perhaps there is a problem with the form?

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Thank you so much! Always glad when I can help people avoid books that aren’t for them 🙂

      Thanks for letting me know about the issue, that’s odd. The email signup should just be the typical WordPress-embedded one. I’ll email their support and ask about it. Since you have a WordPress account you should be able to subscribe to see new posts in your reader if you’d rather that. I’ll see if I can find out anything about the mail subscriber glitch.

      Like

    1. I’ve never tried them but I want to someday! I got so excited in the Wisconsin cheese chapter but that’s when I realized it wasn’t going to be about celebrating what’s special in a region. What a missed opportunity!

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s