High Strangeness and Lore from the Midwest

 Book review: Midwestern Strange, by B.J. Hollars (Amazon / Book Depository)

Professor B.J. Hollars set out, after a challenge from his writing students, to investigate his region’s tales of inexplicable monsters and events of “high strangeness,” that is, “encounters that are improvable either as events or illusions.”

I’ve selected the Midwest as my testing ground because as a midwesterner, I’m well-versed in our region’s oddities. And I’m well aware, too, that most people aren’t. We Middle Americans have grown accustomed to being overlooked, which is precisely why outsiders ought to look a bit closer. The West Coast has its Bigfoot and the East Coast has its Champy, but what–beyond hot dish–could the Midwest possibly provide? Trust me, the Midwest is just as murky and mysterious as the next place.

The Midwest encompasses, in his explorations, a bit more than I usually think of in that region. He loops in the Mothman of Point Pleasant, West Virginia, for example. A minor point, because Hollars is such a charming guide to this weird corner of American folklore and the reasoning giving rise to it that actually, I would’ve read much more of this. I thought before reaching the epilogue that maybe this would be the first in a series (hoping he’d cover the East Coast next because we have lots of beasties and high strangeness too — do the Jersey Devil!)

Alas, in the epilogue, he explains that this exploration had to end. He references the well-known warning of staring into the abyss and finding it staring back. (In his words: “When you embrace the strange too tightly there’s a chance it embraces you back.”)

I enjoyed learning about these stories because they’re strange and unusual, but no matter how bizarre or unlikely, they’re part of our lore for a reason. What Hollars does so well is show why these became ingrained in our imaginations.

Hollars is an author of multiple nonfiction titles on a broad spectrum of topics, and is also an English professor in Wisconsin. He draws on this academic and literary background to establish his position going into this one-year project: “We in academia simply have little patience for the weird: get with the facts and spare us the speculation.” I appreciate that attitude in approaching this topic, I think it’s a better one to have than slack-jawed gullibility. Or, as one woman involved with the Beast of Bray Road tells him, “You should be open-minded, but not so open-minded that your brains fall out the back of your head.”

He doesn’t immediately take the angle of debunking, but also doesn’t accept the stories at face value. Instead, over his year of “living strangely,” he collects stories of monsters, martians, and “the weird” and places them in context to analyze what they reveal about their regions, eras, economics, and something about human nature. He explores the Beast of Bray Road, a bipedal wolf-like animal reported in 1936 in Wisconsin; the Kensington runestone of Minnesota; Oscar, a monster snapping turtle in Churubusco, Indiana and the mild-mannered farmer who became his Ahab; UFOs and a run-in with aliens who came bearing pancakes; and the “Hodag” from northern Wisconsin lumberjack territory, a thoroughly debunked but still ongoing creature hoax with a complicated economic connection to the town of Rhinelander.

The Hodag hoax is an interesting example of how valuable some of these stories are for their communities, even over the long run. Hollars finds that “over fifty local businesses have co-opted the Hodag in some fashion. One can get his oil changed at Hodag Express Lube, then purchase a firearm at Hodag Gun & Loan, then complete the day by enjoying a bit of “Hodag Poop” from the local candy store. The Hodag’s ubiquity is proof of its lasting power, and today, locals know to cash in.”

This is what makes this book especially fascinating — myths don’t materialize from nothing. There’s background, and no short amount of logic, to each of them. He quotes Neil DeGrasse Tyson’s “The Universe is under no obligation to make sense to you,” giving a nod to inexplicable possibility. He’s respectful about those with firmly-held supernatural beliefs and takes a neutral stance between skepticism and acceptance. The results of his explorations are reasonable while still wildly entertaining. But I found that it’s probably more appealing to those of us who insist on logical, scientific explanations for bizarre sightings and unexplained happenings.

And it’s just a lot of fun. He strikes a perfect balance of humor and history, fact and myth, and is a smart, amusing guide to the Midwest’s supernatural mysteries.

Sobering as it is, such a clear-eyed assessment offers the kind of logical conclusion I’m desperate to hear, a counterpoint to the stranger theories I’ve heard. Which is not to discount those theories, but to shed light upon them. Light that, with any luck, refracts back with a better answer.

Midwestern Strange:
Hunting Monsters, Martians, and the Weird in Flyover Country

by B.J. Hollars
published September 1, 2019 by University of Nebraska Press

I received an advance copy courtesy of the publisher for unbiased review.

Amazon / Book Depository


16 thoughts on “High Strangeness and Lore from the Midwest

Add yours

  1. I’m from central Michigan and now live in northern Indiana, and I have not heard of most of these legends! I’m so glad the author doesn’t take himself too seriously, but also tries to be straightforward and practical, so I’ll likely add this book to my TBR. Where I’m from, the “monster” rumors are typically one person saying that saw a rattlesnake/bobcat and everyone else saying, “Yer fulla shit! There’s no rattlesnakes/bobcats in Michigan!” and then something on the news confirms a huge rattlesnake/bobcat WAS sighted. LOL, it’s always scary and funny.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I would so love to hear what you think of it! I know so little about the Midwest in general, even less about stories of this nature, but there’s a heavy cultural perspective tied in. It was just really interesting and his way of exploring and interviewing and weighing scientific opinion vs. anecdotal evidence was well done and entertaining. And lol at those monster rumors! I think a lot of these stories come from things like that, like the Indiana turtle one. People see something that you don’t often see or think doesn’t live around there and it gets exaggerated in the repeated tellings of it. I hope you’ll read it!


  2. Huh. I must admit that the Midwest is not a region that jumps to my mind when thinking about strange happenings and creatures, but they could happen there just as often as New Mexico has alien experiences! 🙂

    Plus – sounds like the author has a good sense of humor.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. The Midwest didn’t come readily to mind for me as a hotspot of weird activity either, but the stories ended up being so interesting! And regionally appropriate…like a monster in a lumberjack town. His sense of humor was great, never mean-spirited or overbearing. It’s a really fun and surprisingly smart read!

      Liked by 1 person

  3. This sounds absolutely fascinating! I love strange myths and things, and have been in the Midwest all my life… plus the way he tackles each story from an angle of “why might people believe (or at least perpetuate) these stories?” rather than trying to prove or debunk them sounds great. I must find a copy. Great review!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. It might be really interesting for you considering your background in the region! That was also what I loved about it, looking at why these stories exist or are perpetuated instead of only retelling them. Glad I could introduce you to it, looking forward to hearing your perspective when you get to it!

      Liked by 1 person

  4. This sounds fun. I don’t think my rather Anglo-centric local library will buy this book though. I am always outraged when they don’t stock a book you recommend – I regard the library as my personal resource 🤪 I do not see why they have fishing and car and knitting magazines which are of no interest to me… in other news, will you be reviewing the new Malcolm Gladwell book about strangers? It sounds interesting but I would like a “whatsnonfiction” seal of approval first. I had never read any Gladwell, wondering if I should and where to start.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I know what you mean, I don’t know what I’d do without the library! This one is from a University Press, so since it’s not one of the major publishers it might be harder for it to make its way internationally. I think you can put in requests for a library to stock something though, can’t you? That might be an option! It was a really fun read, I thought. This kind of topic has the potential to go very wrong but I thought he handled it perfectly. It was enlightening but still fun and funny and thoughtful. And lol @ the magazines! Why does fishing get an entire magazine, seriously…

      I’ve never read a Malcolm Gladwell book either! I didn’t even realize he had a new one. His topics never appealed to me all that much but I just googled that one and it does sound interesting. Maybe I’ll give it a try, I’m not sure yet…let me know if you end up reading it first!

      Liked by 1 person

  5. It gets worse: there are even different magazines for different types of fishing, like The Angler and The Carp Fancier (I may have invented these titles but the general gist is true).

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Lolol I believe those are barely exaggerated but still! How dreadful. Definitely look into the library request option, we can do that in the US. You just submit a title for them to consider and librarians decide if they want to carry it. Although if they’re so interested in cars and fishing, you may have a hard time convincing them on this one 😂


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: