A Long Overdue Comprehensive Biography of Sylvia Plath

Red Comet: The Short Life and Blazing Art of Sylvia Plath (Used or new @ SecondSale.com), by Heather Clark

Now she is flying
More terrible than she ever was, red
Scar in the sky, red comet
Over the engine that killed her—
The mausoleum, the wax house

The book I most surprised myself by reading last year was Red Comet, the 1000+ page biography of Sylvia Plath. Not because I’m uninterested in her life, but I wasn’t sure I was more than a thousand pages interested. (That much material for someone who died at 31!)

But I’d also read Three Martini Afternoons at the Ritz and The Barbizon earlier in the year, and both offered fascinating partial biographies of Plath, enough to make me realize that what I knew of her life was really only the outline and bigger facts, not the little biographical details, which were completely fascinating.

I couldn’t believe how page-turning it was from the get-go. Author Heather Clark sets out her goals in writing this, the most comprehensive biography of the poet, stating that she “tried to recover what Plath gave to us rather than what she gave up.” She shows in startling detail the true breadth of Plath’s accomplishments — underscored by the shockingly short time in which she produced them — and emphasizes how monumental they were considering the extremely sexist standards and norms of Plath’s era.

The foundations of Plath’s life were laid with German/Austrian immigrant parents, leading to a rigidity in her upbringing and personal beliefs and approaches to everything from her work ethic to her child-rearing tendencies. Her parents’ (and other relatives’) lives are explored in connection to major themes and events in Sylvia’s.

And Clark sets this all up so masterfully, weaving in Sylvia’s early poems, letters, and interviews with those who knew her that this really becomes an immersion into her world. I’m not the biggest biography reader, but I’m not sure I’ve ever read one that felt like this — it’s common to hear biographers or historians talk about the years they spent working on a project as really feeling like they were living with their subject, almost inside their heads along with them, but this might have been the first time that as a reader I really felt that connected too.

This is thanks in part to Sylvia’s own voluminous communications and writings, which make her voice so clear ang strong, but also to Clark’s skill as a biographer and understanding of her subject and the atmosphere she lived and worked in. The way she applies this to the present is similarly deft, and she truly achieves her goal of showing the importance of Plath’s contribution to American literature, and not simply a written-off reputation as a “suicide goddess” whose shrine angry young women worship at, a concept also debunked in Three Martini Afternoons at the Ritz.

When we see a female character reading The Bell Jar in a movie, we know she will make trouble.

Of course, living in Sylvia’s world, where depression reared its ugly head sadly early, is not always pleasant. As I remember learning in those other books, she’s a stormy and tumultuous personality. I also felt fairly exhausted at the pace of her work and submissions — contests, literary grants and scholarships, publishers, etc. — although it’s testament to her extraordinary ambition.

Clark also makes clear the links to Plath’s inspirations: T.S. Eliot, Theodore Roethke, W.H. Auden (whose former London home would be Plath’s last home) and maybe this seems too obvious but I understood Plath’s work better having these influences and connections made explicit.

If there was any drawback it was that there was a great amount of focus and text dedicated to when a poem or story was published where, often big lists of this. Obviously these are important, this was her life’s work and her burgeoning successes, but it made for duller reading when the rest of this felt so vibrant.

Otherwise brilliant, well deserved, and long overdue but well worth the wait and scholarship that went into it.


24 thoughts on “A Long Overdue Comprehensive Biography of Sylvia Plath

Add yours

    1. I’m so glad I could convince you. I was hesitant about it too, it just seemed like such a big commitment and I wasn’t sure I was that invested in it! But the writing is outstanding and her life was really so interesting. I learned a lot from it, and I appreciate her writing even more now too. Hope you enjoy it!


    1. Thanks so much!! She really is intriguing, I think even more than I realized. This will definitely make you want to revisit her work (although plenty is scattered throughout here too) and it gave me a whole new appreciation for her writing as well.

      Liked by 1 person

  1. Wonderful review…revealing just enough to spark my interest.
    I know NOTHING about Plath…and it is high time I read this biography ( after I finish 40+ books purchased in 2015 still on my Kindle TBR!)
    I loved the when you mentioned “living in Plath’s head” while reading this biography. I felt the same when reading bio’s about John Updike, Tennessee Williams and abstract Dutch artist (moved to NYC in his early years) De Kooning. Just finished Out of Africa (see blog) and agree with your score on Goodreads…2 stars (…barely).

    Liked by 1 person

    1. This was definitely one of those where you really feel you’re living with the person – it’s not easy but I thought very worthwhile, like I understood her better in some sense. I might have to look into the Tennessee Williams bio, I haven’t read much about him but love his plays.

      I don’t remember much about Out of Africa besides being massively disappointed with it and bewildered why it was such a classic!!


  2. Great review. Sylvia Plath is someone I always heard about, but does not know very much about. I think I have read one book by her. Since I am not sure, I think I have to go back to her. Will definitely look for this biography (I am a big fan of good biographies) and the other two you mentions. Thank you for excellent tips as usual.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. She’s definitely worth a revisit, and it helps so much to better understand where she came from, how she was treated, her relationships. This was book was so outstanding for that. Glad I could point you in this direction!


    1. Now that you mention it I realize that’s the case for me too, I’ve been more hesitant on longer books since I started blogging. But it’s great when you find one that’s so worthwhile and it flies by faster than many shorter books!


  3. I got halfway through this and then it had to go back to the library — it was fascinating but I don’t have much time to read these days! I’m waiting for it to come back to me from the holds list. After reading The Bell Jar this year I had to know more about Plath, and it’s been excellent in giving context to the works and the times she wrote in.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I hope you’ll get to finish it! I was intimidated by it since it’s so massive but I really loved it. I agree, this was so excellent at establishing the context of her time and how she fit into it. Hope you’ll have time and opportunity to get back to it soon!

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: